- Pierpont, Francis H.746
- Pierpont, Francis Harrison185
- Crothers, H. W. 16
- Samuels, Henry J.15
- Wheat, James S.15
- Lamb, Daniel5
- Anisansel, Henry4
- no recipient given4
- Carlile, John S. 3
- Samuels, Henry Jefferson3
- Boggess, H. H.2
- Buffington, A. R.2
- Daum, Philip2
- Frost, Daniel2
- Goshen, W. S.; Lamb, Daniel 2
- Henderson, Joseph2
- Lamb, Daniel; Van Winkle, Peter G.2
- Micah, G. N. J.2
- Michael, John2
- Oakes, James2